Provenance

Joseph Grünling, Vienna (Lugt 1107) (his sale: Vienna, 25 February-19 March, 1823, lot 882, “Calipso priant Télémaque de raconteur ses aventeurs avant de partir pour Chypre. Minerve sous la figure de Mentor, avec une hibon [sic] à côté d’elle, l’écoute—Dessin à la plume et lavé au bistre, à grande touches, sur papier blanc. Pièce faite à Rome en 1809”)

Artaria & Co., Vienna (Lugt 5492) (their sale: Vienna, Dorotheum, Collection Ataria, 7 April 1933, part of 195 [one of six sheets])

Joseph Eferdinger (1871-1941), Vienna (Lugt 5493)

Literature

J. Grünling, Cabinet de J. Grunling: La partie des dessins originaux, Vienna, 1823, no. 882

Our drawing depicts the scene in Homer’s Odyssey (circa 725 B. C.) in which Telemachus, Odysseus’ son, having been shipwrecked on the nymph Calypso’s island with his tutor, Mentor, describes to her their adventures. They were in search of his father, Odysseus, the Greek hero and King of Ithaca, who left his native city to fight in the Trojan War twenty years prior and had still not returned, despite the fall of Troy ten years before. Telemachus is seated with Calypso in the center of the composition, while two of her handmaidens are seated to the left and Mentor, listening to Telemachus, stands to the right. The scene, as tradition has it, occurs in a grotto-like setting, in this instance with a beautiful island landscape and bay beyond. In Homer’s epic poem, Mentor is really Athena, the goddess of Wisdom, in disguise. Her attribute, an owl, can be seen next to Mentor in our drawing. This conforms to mythology, where the owl sits beside Athena’s left leg because she is blind in one eye, thus helping her to see the whole truth. Athena had a special affection for Odysseus and his son, instilling them with the wisdom they needed to be leaders, warriors, and, in the case of Telemachus, a future king.

While Telemachus and Mentor appear in Homer’s Odyssey, they are later the main protagonists in François Fénelon’s didactic novel, Les aventures de Télémaque, first published anonymously in 1699 and reprinted by Fénelon’s family in 1717. This was certainly the literary source for the present sheet, which illustrates a scene from Book I. The novel, comprised of twenty-four books, embellishes the story of Telemachus, and was seen in the eighteenth century as a discourse on good government, with peace, simplicity, and brotherhood rising above war, greed, and selfishness. Fénelon’s ideal was Republican Greece as opposed to Imperial Rome, and Les aventures de Télémaque was taken as a denunciation of autocratic, monarchial rule (specifically, that of Louis XIV) in favor of governance by a constitutional monarchy in which a king would be advised by a council of patriarchs, and disputes between nations would be resolved not by war, but by a federation of nations. The novel, an instant success and immensely popular throughout the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, was translated into every European language, and had a profound effect on Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Thomas Jefferson, who re-read it frequently, and many other Enlightenment figures. It would prove an inspiration to both French Revolutionaries and German Romantics. Espousing the importance of the individual and, equally, an individual’s ties and commitment to family, fatherland, and fellow human being, to a world greater than oneself, Fénelon’s novel was a seminal work in the evolution away from autocracy and towards, ultimately, democracy.

A drawing by Pinelli of the same subject, comparably large and executed in the same technique, is in the Art Institute of Chicago.¹ It is one of twelve drawings by the artist in that collection, all on this grand scale and in this same technique, and all dated 1808, from an album illustrating scenes from The Adventures of Telemachus. Made a year before our sheet, the drawing in Chicago differs from ours in several ways: Telemachus sits to the left of Calypso, and Mentor to the left of Telemachus; seven as opposed to two of Calypso’s nymphs are present; and the scene occurs in an open landscape with a large tree and waterfalls on either side in the mountainous background. Like many of his contemporaries, Pinelli clearly fell under the influence of Fénelon’s Telemachus. Although it would seem likely, it is not known whether our drawing or the Chicago sheets were preparatory for illustrations to a published version of the novel.

Bartolomeo Pinelli, a painter, draftsman, sculptor, and engraver working in early nineteenth-century Rome, portrayed many aspects of everyday life there as well as in the south of Italy. Having studied sculpture with his father, he attended the Academy of Saint Luke in Rome and the Academy of Fine Arts in Bologna. He returned to Rome at the end of the 1790s and sold his work in cafés frequented by tourists on the Grand Tour. His first important series of colored engravings, Raccolta di cinquanta costumi pittoreschi, was published in 1809, the year of our drawing. This was followed by illustrations to Virgil’s Aeneid in 1811, the history of Greece in 1812, and the history of Rome in 1816. Although Pinelli achieved some success as an illustrator in his lifetime, he died destitute in Trastevere, the neighborhood in which he was born.

The present sheet was originally in the distinguished collection of Joseph Grünling at whose 1823 sale it was purchased by the well-known music publishing firm, Artaria & Co., whose clients included amongst other musicians, Mozart, Beethoven, and Haydn. Founded in 1770 in Vienna as a publishing house for art and maps,

Artaria continued to be a leading music publisher through the nineteenth century until the early twentieth century. In 1920, Freytag & Berndt acquired its cartographic publishing business. The publishing business was dissolved in 1932, and its stock of Old Master and modern drawings, including the present sheet, was sold at the Dorotheum in 1933.

Hamburger Kunsthalle, Hamburg

PAST SALES

OLD MASTER DRAWINGS

VENETIAN SCHOOL

Head of a Youth Looking up to the Left

JACOPO ZUCCHI

The Foundation of Cosmopoli (?)

CAMILLO PROCACCINI

Screaming Man

GIUSEPPE CESARI, called CAVALIERE D’ARPINO

An Angel in Flight: Study for the “Ascension of Christ” (S. Giovanni in Laterano, Rome)

CLAUDE GELLÉE, called CLAUDE LORRAIN

Pastoral Landscape with a Figure by a Lake

REMBRANDT HARMENSZ. VAN RIJN

A Young Man Leaning on a Stick, Turned to the Left

MARCO BENEFIAL

A Man on Crutches

JEAN-BAPTISTE GREUZE

Tête d’enfant portant un bonnet, regardant à gauche

GIOVANNI DOMENICO TIEPOLO

The Holy Family Entering Memphis

FRANCISCO JOSE DE GOYA Y LUCIENTES

Tambourine Player

19TH & 20TH CENTURY DRAWINGS

BARTOLOMEO PINELLI

Telemachus Relates his Adventures to Calypso as Mentor Listens, 1809

ADRIEN-VICTOR AUGER

Portrait of the Violinist Jean Vidal

ANTOINE-LOUIS BARYE

Daim merchant vers la droite

JEAN-BAPTISTE-CAMILLE COROT

Young Man in Front of a Great Oak

FERDINAND-VICTOR-EUGÈNE DELACROIX

Un Dessous de bois

HENRI LEHMANN

Reclining Male Figure Embracing a Woman and Two studies of his Left Arm: Study for the Painting “Rêve,” also called “Rêve d’Amour,” 1848

THOMAS COUTURE

Le Pierrot politique

HILAIRE-GERMAIN-EDGAR DEGAS

Portrait in Profile of the Artist’s Brother, René de Gas (recto) Another Study of René, Sleeping (verso)

ADOLPH VON MENZEL

A Young Woman Looking over Her Left Shoulder, and a Study of an Ear, 1886

ODILON REDON

Le Prisonnier à La Lucarne

PAUL CÉZANNE

Lit défait (recto) Arbres au dessus d’un ruisseau (verso)

EVA GONZALÈS

La Plante favorite

GEORGES SEURAT

La pluie

ACHILLE LAUGÉ

Madame Catherine Laugé (née Gazel), the Artist’s Mother

PABLO PICASSO

Homme au gibus, 1915

PAINTINGS, OIL SKETCHES, & SCULPTURE

NICOLAS DE LARGILLIERRE

Portrait de Charles-Léonor Aubry (1673-1728), marquis de Castelnau, conseiller au Parlement de Paris, 1701

ANTON RAPHAEL MENGS

The Glory of Saint Eusebius

SIMON-JOSEPH-ALEXANDRE CLÉMENT DENIS

A Vine Arbor, Ischia

JOHANNES JELGERHUIS

A Young Man Seated at a Writing Desk by Lamplight (Binnenhuis), 1819

PIERRE-JEAN DAVID, called DAVID D’ANGERS

Charles-Nicolas, baron Fabvier (1782-1855), 1829

HORACE VERNET

Portrait of Jean-Louis-André-Théodore Géricault

SAMUEL PALMER

Box Hill, Surrey

HIPPOLYTE-JEAN FLANDRIN

Portrait of René-Charles Dassy (1826-1889) and His Brother Jean-Baptiste-Claude-Amédé Dassy (1827-1908), 1850

PIERRE-ÉTIENNE-THÉODORE ROUSSEAU

La Ferme dans les Landes

PIERRE-ÉTIENNE-THÉODORE ROUSSEAU

Panoramic Landscape near the River Moselle

FRANÇOIS BONVIN

Nature morte aux oeufs, 1878

EUGÈNE-LOUIS BOUDIN

Study of Clouds

WALTER GAY

The Small Red Drawing Room of the Comtesse Robert de Fitz-James, Rue Constantine, Paris